Trusted Property Appraisers in Ohio, Indiana & Michigan – Comprehensive Valuation Services Since 2004

June 3, 2025

When Accuracy Matters, Trust Consolidated Appraisal Services Company

When it comes to making informed decisions about property—whether you’re buying, selling, refinancing, planning your estate, or navigating a legal dispute—having a certified, experienced appraiser is critical. Since 2004, Consolidated Appraisal Services Company has been the trusted name in professional property appraisal across Ohio, Indiana, and Michigan.

With over 21 years of experience, a team of highly qualified and certified appraisers, and deep local market knowledge, we are your go-to resource for precise, defensible property valuations.

Full-Service Property Appraisals You Can Rely On

We specialize in a wide range of real estate appraisal services:

Residential Appraisals Serving counties across Ohio including Auglaize, Allen, Logan, Putnam, and Wyandot.
Commercial Appraisals Covering a broad footprint across Ohio, Indiana, and Michigan.
Agricultural & Farm Appraisals We have specialized experience in farmland, conservation easements, and rural properties.
Litigation & Legal Support Including divorce appraisals, tax dispute valuations, estate planning, and eminent domain cases.
Insurance & Refinancing Appraisals Supporting insurers and financial institutions with accurate assessments.

Service Area: Local Experts with a Tri-State Reach

Whether you’re located in the heart of Lima, the suburbs of Columbus, or rural Jay County, Indiana, our team covers:

Ohio Cities: Lima, Findlay, Columbus, Toledo, Dayton, Marysville, Sidney, Troy, Marion, Gahanna, Westerville, and more.
Residential Counties (OH): Clinton, Highland, Clermont, Brown, Adams, Scioto, Pike, Union, Champaign, Logan, Shelby, Hardin, Van Wert, Auglaize, Allen, Darke, Putnam, Hancock, Mercer.
Commercial Coverage: All of Ohio, Indiana, and Michigan.

We’ve performed thousands of appraisals across the Midwest—and we know the land, laws, and local real estate like no one else.

What Makes Our Appraisal Company Different?

📌 Certified & Experienced:

All our appraisers are state-certified and continuously trained. We bring over two decades of valuation expertise to every job.

📌 Credibility You Can Count On:

Our reports are known for their accuracy, detail, and defensibility—especially when supporting court cases or tax disputes.

📌 Outstanding Reputation:

We’re proud to be BBB A+ rated, and our founder, Tim Harpster, is a past president of ASFMRA and OCAP.

📌 Fast Turnaround with Clear Communication:

Appraisals typically take 2–3 weeks. Need it faster? Rush service is available for an additional fee.

FAQs – Answered by Appraisal Experts

Q: How is the value of a property determined?

We use multiple valuation methods including the sales comparison approach, cost approach, and income approach when applicable.

Q: Can I contest an appraisal?

Absolutely. We always take time to address concerns, provide clarity, and walk clients through the valuation process.

Q: What information do I need to schedule an appraisal?

We’ll need the parcel number or property details, reason for the appraisal, and any lease or easement documentation.

Q: How do you ensure quality?

Every report is reviewed for accuracy and compliance. Our education, ethics, and attention to detail set us apart.

Appraisal Services That Deliver Peace of Mind

At Consolidated Appraisal Services Company, we understand that behind every appraisal is a significant decision. That’s why we approach every assignment with integrity, objectivity, and respect for our clients’ needs.

Whether you’re in Auglaize County, Columbus, Fort Wayne, or anywhere in between, we’re here to deliver trusted results that move you forward.